Why Creators Are Ditching OnlyFans for Fansly (And Cashing In)

💡 OnlyFans vs Fansly: Why Creators in the U.S. Are Switching Sides

Let’s get real for a sec. If you’re a creator in the U.S. in 2025, you’ve probably noticed the winds changing in the adult content game. OnlyFans has been the big dog for years — that name alone can make a grandma blush at Thanksgiving. But recently, a ton of drama, bans, and rumors have creators asking: Is Fansly the new promised land?

Earlier this month, the OnlyFans community was rocked by Bonnie Blue’s permanent ban — and the fallout was messy. Creators everywhere started swapping tips in Discord threads and TikTok comments, worried they might be next in line for a deplatforming [Cosmopolitan, 2025-06-14]. Meanwhile, Fansly’s been quietly stacking up features and fans, offering a fresh start (and often, fatter paychecks) to folks feeling burned by OnlyFans’ crackdown.

There’s a ton of hype — but also a lot of confusion. Is Fansly actually safer? Does it pay more? Can you really build an audience there, or is it just a copycat? And what about all the viral headlines about creator earnings, bans, and the next big thing after OnlyFans? That’s exactly what we’re digging into today.

Whether you’re a creator, a fan, or just nosy about internet money, this showdown is about way more than thirst traps and spicy DMs. It’s about control, cash flow, and who really calls the shots in the wild world of online adult content. Let’s break down what’s changing, what’s staying the same, and how to actually make these platforms work for you in 2025.

📊 OnlyFans vs Fansly: Platform Feature Showdown (2025)

What jumps out? Fansly is clearly playing the underdog card — lower creator fees (15% vs OnlyFans’ 20%), faster payouts, and a vibe that’s just more welcoming to niche or edgy creators. OnlyFans is still the Goliath with a massive user base, but their discoverability features are meh at best (seriously, most creators still have to hustle on X or Reddit to get noticed). Fansly’s trending and explore tabs are giving smaller creators a shot at going viral inside the app — something OnlyFans just doesn’t offer.

The real kicker? Policy. With OnlyFans, there’s always that “what if I get banned next?” fear. In the past month alone, bans like Bonnie Blue’s have gone viral, causing a rush of creators to back up their content and look for safer ground [Hindustan Times, 2025-06-14]. Fansly, on the other hand, has been more transparent and supportive, especially for folks in kink, fetish, or LGBTQ+ spaces.

And don’t sleep on the tech upgrades: Fansly’s mobile app, advanced DM tools, and in-platform promos make it easier to connect with fans without having to grind on five other social platforms. But the biggest surprise? Fansly is now the fastest-growing platform in the U.S., even if its total user base is still smaller. The energy is shifting, and for creators who want more control (and less drama), that’s a big deal.

💡 What Real Creators Are Saying: Money, Bans & Community

Let’s talk dollars and drama, because that’s what’s fueling this migration. OnlyFans made headlines last week when star creator Sophie Rain pulled back the curtain on her 2025 earnings — and let’s just say, it’s eye-watering. But behind those viral paydays, there’s a harsh reality: OnlyFans’ 20% cut and unpredictable bans are pushing mid-level creators to rethink where they build their empires [NY Post, 2025-06-14].

The Bonnie Blue saga is still the talk of the town: one day she’s trending, the next she’s gone — account nuked, income wiped, fans scrambling to find her new handle. The story even had regulars on r/OnlyFansAdvice and TikTok up in arms, debating if anyone is safe on the platform anymore [Cosmopolitan, 2025-06-14]. For a lot of U.S. creators, Fansly became the obvious lifeboat.

Fansly isn’t perfect — it’s still smaller, and you won’t get those random celeb shoutouts just for joining. But the vibe is more community-driven. Creators say Fansly’s team actually listens, responds to ticket requests, and takes a real stand against hate or harassment. Plus, the algorithm loves niche — if you’re into cosplay, foot stuff, or weirdly specific ASMR, you’ll find your people here faster than on OnlyFans.

Another wild trend? Newbies are running both accounts (OnlyFans for clout, Fansly for stability). But the numbers don’t lie: Fansly’s lower fees, faster payouts, and “discoverability-first” approach are helping regular creators hit four-figure months without going viral. The risk of a platform ban still exists, but it feels way less random — and that peace of mind is priceless when your rent depends on your next DM drop.

Looking ahead, with OnlyFans founder Tim Stokely launching “Subs” — a new rival platform aiming for both SFW and NSFW audiences — competition is only going to get fiercer. But for now, the U.S. creator crowd is voting with their wallets and their time. The message is clear: loyalty to a platform only goes so far if the rules keep changing and your earnings aren’t safe.

🙋 Frequently Asked Questions

❓ Why are creators leaving OnlyFans for Fansly in 2025?
💬 Honestly? A lot of folks are just tired of the random bans and lack of discoverability on OnlyFans. Fansly offers lower fees, better promo tools, and more freedom for edgy or niche content. Plus, with stories like Bonnie Blue’s permanent ban making headlines, creators want a more stable home for their business.

🛠️ Is it risky to switch platforms as a U.S. creator?
💬 A little, but not as bad as you think! Most creators keep accounts on both to test the waters. Fansly’s onboarding is slick, and they’ve been way more transparent about policy changes. Just back up your audience and content before moving.

🧠 What’s the biggest mistake newbies make choosing between OnlyFans and Fansly?
💬 Getting blinded by big names or hype. The real winners are those who build a loyal fanbase, use promo tools, and diversify. Don’t expect to go viral day one — community and consistency matter more than platform alone.

🧩 Final Thoughts…

So, who wins the “OnlyFans vs Fansly” war? Honestly, it depends on what you want — but if you’re a U.S. creator in 2025, Fansly is looking like the hotter ticket for steady growth, better support, and less random drama. The power shift is real, and the smart creators are hedging their bets, building on both, and moving with the market instead of letting the market move them.

Don’t get caught sleeping. If you’re serious about your creator business, keep your options open, watch the news, and don’t let any platform hold your career hostage. The fans will follow you — as long as you keep showing up.

📚 Further Reading

Here are 3 recent articles that give more context to this topic — all selected from verified sources. Feel free to explore 👇

🔸 3 OnlyFans creators weigh in on Bonnie Blue’s shock, ‘permanent’ OF ban
🗞️ Source: Cosmopolitan – 📅 2025-06-14
🔗 Read Article

🔸 Why has Bonnie Blue been banned by OnlyFans? Details here
🗞️ Source: Hindustan Times – 📅 2025-06-14
🔗 Read Article

🔸 OnlyFans star Sophie Rain reveals the wild amount of money she’s making in 2025 — and whether or not she is still a virgin
🗞️ Source: NY Post – 📅 2025-06-14
🔗 Read Article

😅 A Quick Shameless Plug (Hope You Don’t Mind)

If you’re creating on OnlyFans, Fansly, or similar platforms — don’t let your content go unnoticed.

🔥 Join Top10Fans — the global ranking hub built to spotlight creators like YOU.

✅ Ranked by region & category

✅ Trusted by fans in 100+ countries

🎁 Limited-Time Offer: Get 1 month of FREE homepage promotion when you join now!

📌 Disclaimer

This post blends publicly available information with a touch of AI assistance. It’s meant for sharing and discussion purposes only — not all details are officially verified. Please take it with a grain of salt and double-check when needed.