Why U.S. Creators Are Dumping OnlyFans for Fansly & ShagLive (And How Much They’re Really Making)

💡 Why Are U.S. Creators Suddenly Flocking to Fansly and ShagLive?

Alright, let’s get real for a sec. If you’re hustling in the U.S. creator game — whether you’re just a little spicy on TikTok or full-blown adult content queen — you’ve felt the ground shifting. After years of OnlyFans ruling the roost, 2024 and 2025 have been straight-up wild.

Big names like Bonnie Blue aren’t just making headlines for wild stunts (or even wilder earnings), they’re also jumping ship — starting over on new platforms like Fansly, sometimes pulling in nearly $100k in just hours. Word on the street? Fans are following, cash is flowing, and the pressure is on. ShagLive, meanwhile, is blowing up with its own flavor: think instant cam shows, fast tipping, and the promise of a more “live” experience, less about the backlog and more about the now.

So what’s driving this mass exodus and re-shuffling? Short answer: creators want control, better payouts, and a backup plan if/when OnlyFans gets messy (which, let’s face it, happens a lot). Plus, new platforms offer better privacy, unique features, and — for some — a chance to start fresh without the baggage. But which one’s really winning in the U.S.? Let’s break down the numbers, the vibes, and what real creators are saying.

📊 Fansly vs ShagLive: Feature & Earning Comparison (2025)

*OnlyFans data included for reference.

What’s the play here? The table tells a pretty loud story: OnlyFans is still king for average monthly earnings, but Fansly’s catching up fast — especially for creators who want more privacy controls and flexible subscription tiers. ShagLive is hot for folks who thrive on live camming and quick-turn tips, but earnings are a bit lower on average, and the grind can be real. Fansly’s faster payouts and creator-first features are making it the cool new home for those burned by platform drama or just looking to diversify. U.S. creators, especially, love that they can pivot to Fansly or ShagLive without losing their whole fan base — it’s all about spreading the risk and chasing new money streams.

💡 What’s the Real U.S. Buzz? Public Opinion, Trends & Hot Takes

If you’ve spent any time on Reddit, Twitter (X), or even the DMs of spicy TikTok, you know: American creators are way more vocal about where their cash goes and how platforms treat them. In 2025, privacy and payout speed matter more than ever. Fansly’s become a go-to for U.S. creators who got burned on OnlyFans when content rules suddenly changed or when banking issues hit — and let’s not forget the infamous “OF Purge” that left a bunch of top earners scrambling to rebuild.

Bonnie Blue’s wild success story (nearly $100k in hours, $700k+ monthly average) after jumping to Fansly wasn’t a fluke — it was a wakeup call. U.S. creators saw you could start over, bring your loyal fans, and actually earn more if you played your cards right. Meanwhile, ShagLive’s “live or bust” approach is drawing in cam veterans and newbies alike, but some say it’s a tough grind unless you’re always online or have a super engaged audience.

Regular folks? They’re spending big, too: New Yorkers alone dropped millions on OnlyFans last year, showing there’s plenty of appetite for paid content, even as more platforms rise up. Still, as Skins star Megan Prescott recently revealed, the adult creator grind isn’t as easy or glamorous as it looks — most folks aren’t millionaires, but they’re building real, sustainable side hustles that pay the bills and then some[The Tab, 2025-06-23][TimeOut New York, 2025-06-23][LADbible, 2025-06-23].

Prediction time: Expect to see more U.S. creators running multi-platform ops — Fansly for main subs, ShagLive for live tips, and even a “legacy” OnlyFans for old loyalists. The days of all-in on one app? Over. It’s all about stacking your streams, building community, and keeping your digital hustle future-proof.

🙋 Frequently Asked Questions

❓ What makes Fansly different from ShagLive for U.S. creators?

💬 Fansly leans hard into privacy, custom content, and creator tools. ShagLive is all about instant connection: think live cams, fast tips, and quick chats. If you want to build a loyal sub base and push out premium content, Fansly’s your jam. If you want fast, flirty action with big tipping potential, ShagLive’s got perks — but it’s more competitive and less about long-term fans.

🛠️ Is it true that people are making huge money on these platforms now?

💬 Totally! Some folks (think Bonnie Blue-level) are raking in five to six figures monthly, especially after big public jumps from one app to another. But, for most U.S. creators, average income is lower — it’s the hustle, the niche, and how you connect that set you apart. Don’t believe every TikTok ‘overnight millionaire’ story, but yes, the money is real for those who work it.

🧠 Should I switch from OnlyFans to Fansly or ShagLive in 2025?

💬 Honestly? Diversify. OnlyFans’ drama (and cash) isn’t going away, but Fansly and ShagLive are hot for U.S. creators looking to hedge their bets, offer something new, or escape platform bans. Build a presence on all three if you can handle it — your fans will follow where you lead (and where they get the best experience).

🧩 Final Thoughts…

The creator economy’s gone full choose-your-own-adventure, and in the U.S. especially, nobody’s got time to put all their eggs in one basket. Fansly and ShagLive both have their hype — and their headaches — but the smartest move is to play the field, test what works, and keep your fans (and money) moving with you. Remember: platforms will keep changing, but your hustle, your personality, and your community? That’s what’ll get you paid. Stay savvy, stay flexible, and whatever you do — don’t sleep on the new platforms trying to win you over.

📚 Further Reading

Here are 3 recent articles that give more context to this topic — all selected from verified sources. Feel free to explore 👇

🔸 Amanda Bynes shares weight loss goal as she starts Ozempic after joining OnlyFans
🗞️ Source: Daily Mail – 📅 2025-06-23
🔗 Read Article

🔸 Bonnie Blue finally explains why she has beef with Lily Phillips, and she didn’t hold back
🗞️ Source: The Tab – 📅 2025-06-23
🔗 Read Article

🔸 Farrah Abraham on ‘Male Toxicity’ at Teen Mom, How Much She Makes on OnlyFans
🗞️ Source: TooFab – 📅 2025-06-23
🔗 Read Article

😅 A Quick Shameless Plug (Hope You Don’t Mind)

If you’re creating on OnlyFans, Fansly, or similar platforms — don’t let your content go unnoticed.

🔥 Join Top10Fans — the global ranking hub built to spotlight creators like YOU.

✅ Ranked by region & category

✅ Trusted by fans in 100+ countries

🎁 Limited-Time Offer: Get 1 month of FREE homepage promotion when you join now!

📌 Disclaimer

This post blends publicly available information with a touch of AI assistance. It’s meant for sharing and discussion purposes only — not all details are officially verified. Please take it with a grain of salt and double-check when needed.