Why Creators Are Picking Sides: Fansly vs JustForFans Showdown

💡 Fansly vs JustForFans in 2025: Real Talk on Rule Changes & Where Creators Are Flocking

Let’s be real — if you’re making a living (or side hustle) off spicy content in 2025, you know the creator economy is getting wild. Platforms rise and fall overnight, rules change on a dime, and what worked for you last year could get your account nuked today. The big buzz lately? The “Fansly vs JustForFans” debate — and honestly, it’s not just about payouts or who’s got the hottest features. It’s about who’s got your back when the rulebook gets burned.

Here’s what’s got creators talking right now: Fansly, once the up-and-comer for folks fleeing OnlyFans, just dropped a bombshell Terms of Service update. Public, suggestive, and furry content? All banned, as of June 28. The move, pretty clearly pushed by payment processors, left creators panicking — some scrubbing thousands of dollars of content overnight, others rage-tweeting about the rug-pull. Meanwhile, JustForFans keeps quietly plugging along — smaller, but more “chill” about what you post (as long as it’s legal).

But here’s the thing: with stars like Bonnie Blue (the whistleblower who helped spark the latest OnlyFans drama) ditching OF and blowing up on Fansly — and with fans and creators alike trying to figure out where to land — the stakes are higher than ever. So, what’s the real deal in July 2025? Is Fansly still the safe bet, or is JustForFans about to have its moment? Let’s break down the numbers, the vibes, and the stuff nobody else will tell you.

📊 Fansly vs JustForFans: Platform Feature Face-Off (2025)

So what’s the story this table tells? First, all three platforms take the same 20% cut — no surprises there. But the real shake-up is the new Fansly TOS: creators who built their brands on edgy, public, or furry content are suddenly out in the cold. Fansly’s audience is still massive (7M+), but the rule changes could shift the balance. JustForFans? Smaller crowd, but a lot of creators say it feels safer for “niche” or taboo content, and their payout is a bit faster too. OnlyFans is still the big dog, but has become so mainstream and restrictive that a lot of creators are looking to diversify, not rely on it alone.

Key takeaway: It’s not just about where the fans are, but what kind of content you’re allowed to serve — and how fast you get paid if things go sideways. In this climate, “platform hopping” is the new normal, and playing it safe means keeping your eggs in more than one basket.

💡 Beyond the Numbers: Real-World Vibes, Creator Stories, and Trend Predictions

Let’s dig deeper than the fine print. This year, the creator scene feels more unpredictable than a TikTok FYP — with public opinion and platform loyalty flipping every time a headline drops. When Bonnie Blue, once one of the top-earning OnlyFans stars, got booted and then made nearly $100K on Fansly in hours, it sent a message: your audience will follow you… but only if you’re fast, transparent, and keep them in the loop [Radar Online, 2025-07-03].

But here’s the twist — Fansly’s June 2025 crackdown left a lot of those loyal fans (and their favorite creators) feeling betrayed. Social feeds blew up with creators posting “moving sale” links, warning subs their content would disappear, or straight up dunking on Fansly’s sudden pivot. Some folks even started seeing JustForFans as the “last safe haven” for edgier stuff, especially as its leadership continues to signal support for indie and LGBTQ+ creators.

Meanwhile, stories like the guy in Shreveport blowing company money on OnlyFans subscriptions [KEEL News, 2025-07-03] and tabloid drama about record-breaking “events” keep the adult creator world in the headlines — not always for the best reasons. That spotlight is a double-edged sword: more mainstream attention brings more rules, and more risk for anyone relying on a single platform for their livelihood.

What’s next? My prediction: JustForFans keeps growing quietly, scooping up niche creators burned by Fansly’s new rules. Fansly, meanwhile, will probably stay king of the “mainstream alt” crowd — but only for content that fits the new TOS. The real winners? Creators who treat their brand like a business, build email lists, and keep their fans close no matter what platform they’re on. And remember, as Bonnie Blue herself said, “There’s space for everyone — if you’re willing to adapt” [US Magazine, 2025-06-30].

🙋 Frequently Asked Questions

❓ What happened with Fansly’s new content rules in June 2025?

💬 Fansly rolled out a pretty strict Terms of Service update in late June 2025, banning public, suggestive, and furry content. This left a lot of creators scrambling to edit or delete posts before the June 28 deadline, worried about losing income or entire accounts. The changes seem to be pressure from payment processors, not just Fansly’s own policies.

🛠️ Who is Bonnie Blue, and why is she always making headlines?

💬 Bonnie Blue is a UK-based adult creator who was a top star on OnlyFans before moving to Fansly after a high-profile ban. She’s known for breaking records, stirring controversy, and being super open about her moves in the creator economy — which is why she pops up in so many news stories.

🧠 Is it safer to build a brand on Fansly or JustForFans now?

💬 Honestly, both have pros and cons. Fansly is bigger with more buzz, but its recent rule changes have some creators spooked. JustForFans is smaller and more niche, but often seen as “friendlier” to sex workers and indie creators. The real trick? Diversify! Build your fanbase across multiple places so you’re not left scrambling if one platform changes the rules overnight.

🧩 Final Thoughts…

If you’ve made it this far, you already know: there’s no “forever home” in the creator economy. Platforms will keep shifting goalposts, and what’s safe today could be off-limits tomorrow. But if you stay sharp, build real connections with your fans, and keep your brand flexible, you’re way ahead of the game. Fansly vs JustForFans? There’s no one-size-fits-all answer — but now you’ve got the inside scoop to make your next move.

📚 Further Reading

Here are 3 recent articles that give more context to this topic — all selected from verified sources. Feel free to explore 👇

🔸 Why Bonnie Blue Doesn’t Think There’s Competition Between Her and Other Creators (Exclusive)
🗞️ Source: US Magazine – 📅 2025-06-30
🔗 Read Article

🔸 Shreveport Man Arrested for Using Company Money for OnlyFans
🗞️ Source: KEEL News – 📅 2025-07-03
🔗 Read Article

🔸 Bonnie Blue Whistleblower Has Zero Regrets About Sparking OnlyFans Ban
🗞️ Source: Radar Online – 📅 2025-07-03
🔗 Read Article

😅 A Quick Shameless Plug (Hope You Don’t Mind)

If you’re creating on OnlyFans, Fansly, or similar platforms — don’t let your content go unnoticed.

🔥 Join Top10Fans — the global ranking hub built to spotlight creators like YOU.

✅ Ranked by region & category

✅ Trusted by fans in 100+ countries

🎁 Limited-Time Offer: Get 1 month of FREE homepage promotion when you join now!

📌 Disclaimer

This post blends publicly available information with a touch of AI assistance. It’s meant for sharing and discussion purposes only — not all details are officially verified. Please take it with a grain of salt and double-check when needed.