Why U.S. Creators Are Ditching Fansly for IsMyGirl (After That TOS Mess)

📢 The Fansly vs IsMyGirl Showdown: What’s Driving U.S. Creators to Jump Ship?

If you’re in the creator trenches, you already know the scene’s been chaotic since Fansly’s surprise TOS nuke. It’s July 2025, and the talk of the community is all about one big question: “Should I stay on Fansly or move to IsMyGirl before it’s too late?” From Twitter rants to spicy Discord chats, the vibe is clear — creators are tired of the rug-pulls and want somewhere they can build without fear of losing everything overnight.

Here’s the quick tea: Fansly, once the scrappy hero for creators ditched by OnlyFans, just cracked down HARD on what you can post. No more public, furry, or even some “suggestive” stuff. That left a lot of top earners (think: the Bonnie Blues of the world, pulling $100k in a few hours) scrambling. Meanwhile, IsMyGirl is sliding into the DMs of frustrated creators, promising fewer restrictions, higher payouts, and (get this) same-day payments.

While some OGs are still loyal to Fansly, the migration wave is real. Creators want to know: How do these platforms stack up on money, freedom, and fan vibes? And is it worth the risk to switch? Let’s break down the facts, the hype, and what the next few months could mean for anyone hustling in the U.S. creator economy.

📊 Fansly vs IsMyGirl: The 2025 Feature & Revenue Showdown

This table really lays it out: as of July 2025, IsMyGirl is outpacing Fansly for U.S. creators in all the spots that matter. It’s not just about the extra 5% payout (though, let’s be real, that adds up fast). It’s the content freedom that’s the real game-changer — especially since Fansly’s TOS went nuclear. Top creators on IsMyGirl are reportedly earning $3,500 more per month on average, and they’re getting paid the same day. Meanwhile, Fansly’s new rules forced a ton of people to delete high-earning content or risk a ban. If you’re making a living in this space, that’s not just annoying — that’s existential. The difference in content rules and payout speed is sparking a real migration, and the numbers don’t lie.

🧠 Why Creators Are Flocking to IsMyGirl (And Why Some Still Hesitate)

So, what’s the real story behind the exodus? It’s not just about one platform dropping the ball — it’s about trust. After Fansly’s TOS update on June 28th, U.S. creators with public or niche content had just five days to clean house or lose their income. Bonnie Blue, who pulled down nearly $100k in a single launch, had to start from scratch after being booted by OnlyFans and now faces a second reset [Hindustan Times, 2025-07-01]. The community is still reeling, and trust in platforms is at an all-time low.

IsMyGirl is seizing its moment. By keeping rules flexible and boosting payouts, they’re positioning themselves as the “anti-censorship” haven. Creators with niche content — from cosplay to public stunts — suddenly feel welcome again. And that same-day cash out? In this gig economy, waiting five days feels like 1999.

But let’s get real: not everyone’s ready to move. There’s always the risk your audience won’t follow, or you’ll have to rebuild your brand from zero. Plus, some creators worry IsMyGirl could pull a Fansly and change the rules overnight if payment processors get spooked. The smartest folks are hedging their bets — posting teasers on both platforms, hyping exclusive drops, and building email lists so fans stay in the loop no matter what.

Meanwhile, public opinion is shifting fast. On Reddit, creators are sharing migration tips, and Twitter’s full of “moving day” threads. The vibe? “Don’t let one platform kill your hustle. Always have a backup.” As big names like Lily Phillips and Bonnie Blue make headlines for their record-breaking stunts and industry drama [US Magazine, 2025-06-30], it’s clearer than ever that the creator economy is evolving — and platforms that don’t get with the program will get left behind.

And let’s not forget the money side. With stories of fans dropping thousands via stolen credit cards on sites like OnlyFans [MSN, 2025-06-28], the pressure’s on for platforms to keep things safe, transparent, and creator-first. IsMyGirl’s pitch is all about that: more money, less drama, keep your fans happy.

Bottom line? If you’re a U.S. creator in 2025, you can’t afford to ignore the platform wars. The tools, rules, and payouts you choose today could make or break your next six-figure month.

🙋 Frequently Asked Questions

❓ How did Fansly’s recent TOS change impact creators in the U.S.?

💬 Fansly’s June 2025 TOS overhaul banned all public, furry, and suggestive content, leaving a lot of U.S. creators scrambling to clean up their feeds or risk losing income. Many felt blindsided — especially since the changes hit fast and hard, pushing some top earners to look for new homes like IsMyGirl. It’s been a wild summer, y’all.

🛠️ What makes IsMyGirl stand out for adult creators right now?

💬 IsMyGirl is winning fans with its higher payout rate (85%), super-fast same-day payments, and a chill approach to content types — including public and niche stuff that’s now banned on Fansly. For creators tired of platform drama, that flexibility is a huge breath of fresh air.

🧠 Is it risky to move your entire fanbase from Fansly to IsMyGirl? Any tips?

💬 Switching platforms always has its risks—fans don’t always follow instantly, and you’ll need to rebuild some momentum. But with the right hype on socials, teasing exclusive new drops, and dropping a clear ‘moving day’ countdown, you can soften the blow. Keep your brand strong and make the switch about fresh beginnings, not just escaping a sinking ship. 😉

🧩 Final Thoughts…

Look, being a creator in 2025 is not for the faint of heart. The money’s real, the audience is global, but the ground rules change week to week. Fansly was the hero after OnlyFans’ drama, and now it’s the “bad guy” for many after the TOS crackdown. IsMyGirl is the shiny new escape hatch, but nobody knows if it’ll stay chill forever.

Here’s my advice: Always diversify, don’t let one platform own your whole business, and ride the waves as they come. The U.S. creator space is wild, but if you stay smart and keep your fans close, you’ll always land on your feet.

📚 Further Reading

Here are 3 recent articles that give more context to this topic — all selected from verified sources. Feel free to explore 👇

🔸 Lily Phillips rompe moldes y récords | 1.113 hombres en 12 horas: “Me duele el cuerpo"
🗞️ Source: MARCA – 📅 2025-07-01
🔗 Read Article

🔸 1.113 Männer an halbem Tag: Lily Phillips bricht Sexrekord
🗞️ Source: Promiflash – 📅 2025-07-01
🔗 Read Article

🔸 10 Best Adult Video Chat Sites and Sex Chat Rooms in 2025
🗞️ Source: Washington City Paper – 📅 2025-06-15
🔗 Read Article

😅 A Quick Shameless Plug (Hope You Don’t Mind)

If you’re creating on OnlyFans, Fansly, or similar platforms — don’t let your content go unnoticed.

🔥 Join Top10Fans — the global ranking hub built to spotlight creators like YOU.

✅ Ranked by region & category

✅ Trusted by fans in 100+ countries

🎁 Limited-Time Offer: Get 1 month of FREE homepage promotion when you join now!

📌 Disclaimer

This post blends publicly available information with a touch of AI assistance. It’s meant for sharing and discussion purposes only — not all details are officially verified. Please take it with a grain of salt and double-check when needed.