Creators Are Ditching OnlyFans for Fansly vs FanOnly: Here’s the Real Reason

📢 Creators on the Run: Why “Fansly vs FanOnly” Is the Hottest Debate

If you’re anywhere near the adult creator scene in the US, you’ve seen the tsunami of drama this summer. OnlyFans — once the undisputed kingpin — just keeps tightening the screws on what you can and can’t post. In June 2025, the shockwaves hit hard with the high-profile booting of top stars like Bonnie Blue, whose bans and public beefs sent smaller creators scrambling to rethink their whole business model. Sound familiar? [The Tab, 2025-06-26]

Enter Fansly and FanOnly — two platforms that, honestly, used to live in OnlyFans’ shadow. Now? They’re at the center of every “creator migration” thread, Twitter space, and spicy TikTok stitch. The big question isn’t just “which is better?” It’s: Which one actually lets me make bank without getting nuked for a dumb policy change?

Fansly drew headlines when a 25-year-old Brit creator (yeah, her) pulled in nearly $100K in hours after leaving OnlyFans, even starting over with just a handful of pics and vids. Meanwhile, FanOnly’s been quietly building a rep for being less judgy about niche content, and charging creators lower fees. But as of late June, Fansly shocked everyone with a sudden TOS update — banning furry, public, and most “suggestive” content [Futurism, 2025-06-26].

No wonder group chats are on fire. If you’re a creator, you probably just want the real scoop: Where can you post what you want, keep your fans, and not get screwed on payouts? Let’s break it down.

📊 Fansly vs FanOnly vs OnlyFans: Platform Showdown (2025)

Let’s talk takeaways. OnlyFans still has the biggest whales — top earners rake in more than a million a month (yeah, wild). But that comes with a catch: strict rules, surprise bans, and a 20% cut to the house. Fansly was the go-to for ex-OnlyFans creators craving stability and tech perks, but their June 2025 TOS crackdown shocked everyone, banning whole genres overnight. FanOnly slides in with a lower 15% fee and a more chill approach to most niches (so far), but doesn’t have quite the same traffic or earning ceiling. For US creators, the landscape just got way murkier — and the usual “pick the biggest” answer isn’t so obvious anymore.

🔍 What’s REALLY Happening: The Street-Level View

Let’s get real: nobody likes moving platforms. It’s a pain. You lose subs, gotta rebuild, and risk burning your best fans. But in 2025, creators are in “survival mode.” After Bonnie Blue’s messy exit — and the public warnings leading up to her ban [The Tab, 2025-06-26] — the writing was on the wall for a lot of “borderline” creators. OnlyFans’ new extra-strict TOS is enforced by both AI and manual review. That means even a hint of policy gray area can get you shadowbanned, demonetized, or axed with zero notice.

Fansly jumped in as the “safe haven” — more modern tools, friendlier support, and, until recently, way fewer bans. But the June 2025 rules update nuked entire communities overnight. Furry creators, public-content folks, and those who push the “suggestive” envelope had to delete tons of work or risk losing everything [Futurism, 2025-06-26]. Some see this as Fansly caving to the same pressures (banks, payment processors, etc.) that made OnlyFans clamp down.

So where does FanOnly fit? It’s kind of the “scrappy underdog.” Their 15% fee looks sweet, and they’re still letting most niche content slide, as long as it’s not public sex or outright illegal. The tradeoff? Smaller fanbase, less hype, and not as much built-in spend. But if you’re in a newly “banned” genre, FanOnly might be your only shot.

The US creator community is buzzing. Some are playing it like stocks: cross-posting to all three sites, watching which one blows up, and jumping ship as soon as the next TOS bombshell drops. Others are going all-in on FanOnly, banking on the platform’s “creator-first” rep. Word on the street is that more creators are holding backup accounts — just in case. If you’re just starting out? Don’t let the hype fool you: the grind is real, and the platform that’s “safe” today could flip tomorrow.

And don’t forget the money. As The Economist pointed out, sex work is just another gig in the creator economy now — but with a lot more risk and almost no job security [The Economist, 2025-06-26]. With platforms fighting over rules, payouts, and who gets to stay, creators are getting smarter — and way more suspicious.

🙋 Frequently Asked Questions

❓ Why did so many creators leave OnlyFans recently?

💬 A bunch of big names got booted or fed up with stricter content rules, like Bonnie Blue, who bounced after repeated warnings and a permanent ban. The pressure from payment processors and new policies made a lot of creators look for other homes.

🛠️ Can you move your content from OnlyFans to Fansly or FanOnly?

💬 Technically, you gotta re-upload and rebuild — no one-click migration. Some creators start from scratch on Fansly or FanOnly, while others tease old content on socials to bring fans over. It’s grunt work, but loyal fans usually follow.

🧠 Is Fansly safer for creators after the June 2025 TOS update?

💬 Honestly, it’s a mixed bag. The new TOS banned a lot — like public, furry, and even suggestive stuff — and that’s left people scrambling. If your niche is now restricted, FanOnly’s looking more attractive. But if you play by the new rules, Fansly’s tech and payouts are still strong.

🧩 Final Thoughts…

Let’s call it like it is: There’s no “forever home” in this game. OnlyFans is still the money king, but it’s also the strictest. Fansly looked like the chosen one, until their own TOS drama. FanOnly’s the chill new kid, but with less reach. If you’re a US creator chasing freedom, steady income, and fewer headaches, you gotta weigh everything — fees, rules, your niche, and where your fans are willing to follow. Back up your content, keep your socials hot, and never put all your eggs in one basket. The only sure thing? Change is coming, and the smartest creators are always ready to pivot.

📚 Further Reading

Here are 3 recent articles that give more context to this topic — all selected from verified sources. Feel free to explore 👇

🔸 Rick Owens is Opening an OnlyFans Account for His Feet
🗞️ Source: Yahoo Entertainment – 📅 2025-06-24
🔗 Read Article

🔸 Inside OnlyFans University, where the next generation of Bonnie Blues do ‘gay for pay’ lessons
🗞️ Source: The Tab – 📅 2025-06-26
🔗 Read Article

🔸 Harry Potter star reveals ‘desperate’ OnlyFans videos including pouring strawberry milk in her hair to pay off £8k debt
🗞️ Source: The Sun – 📅 2025-06-25
🔗 Read Article

😅 A Quick Shameless Plug (Hope You Don’t Mind)

If you’re creating on OnlyFans, Fansly, or similar platforms — don’t let your content go unnoticed.

🔥 Join Top10Fans — the global ranking hub built to spotlight creators like YOU.

✅ Ranked by region & category

✅ Trusted by fans in 100+ countries

🎁 Limited-Time Offer: Get 1 month of FREE homepage promotion when you join now!

📌 Disclaimer

This post blends publicly available information with a touch of AI assistance. It’s meant for sharing and discussion purposes only — not all details are officially verified. Please take it with a grain of salt and double-check when needed.