Real Talk: Creators Spill on Fansly vs Bonzy—Who’s Winning in 2025?

📢 Fansly vs Bonzy: The Real, Unfiltered Showdown for U.S. Creators

Alright, let’s get real for a sec. If you’re even a little bit plugged into the online creator scene in the U.S., you’ve heard the buzz: Fansly and Bonzy are squaring off, and the stakes are higher than ever. Gone are the days when OnlyFans was the only game in town. Now, with creators (and fans) getting pickier about where they spend their time and money, the “Fansly vs Bonzy” debate is everywhere — from Reddit threads to spicy TikTok leaks and late-night group chats.

Why’s everyone obsessing over these two? Well, it’s not just about more money (though, let’s be honest, that’s a big part). It’s about platform vibe, creative freedom, support, and who’s actually looking out for creators, not just cashing in on their hustle. After some wild drama — like British star Bonnie Blue getting the boot from OnlyFans and then raking in $100k on Fansly in HOURS — the migration is real. But now Bonzy’s here, promising even fatter cuts and smarter tools. The question on every hustler’s mind: which platform’s going to make you rich (or at least help you avoid burnout)?

We dug deep, checked the stats, and stalked some of the U.S.’s biggest creators and their fans. Let’s break down why this rivalry is blowing up, what “winning” looks like, and what’s just hype. Buckle up — this isn’t your usual platform review.

📊 Fansly vs Bonzy: Platform Showdown for U.S. Creators (2025)

Check these numbers. Fansly’s still king for top-tier creators, clocking in with average monthly earnings over $700k for their 1% club — thanks in part to folks like Bonnie Blue, who famously made six figures on her first day after getting banned by OnlyFans (The Tab, 2025-06-23). But look at Bonzy: they’re throwing out a juicier revenue split (creators keep 85%!) and their user base is growing even faster — 61% jump year-over-year, compared to Fansly’s solid but slower 38%.

Feature-wise, Bonzy’s going full “next gen” with instant payouts (seriously, no more waiting for your cash), anonymous fan tipping, and AI-powered DMs that auto-respond to thirsty fans. Fansly, meanwhile, is betting on quality: custom content tiers, NFT drops, and some of the strictest moderation around (for better or worse).

Bottom line: Fansly’s where the big money’s at — for now. But Bonzy’s cooking up a growth story that could totally flip the script by this time next year.

💡 Why Are Creators Jumping Ship? The Vibe Check

You’d think the money would settle things, but talk to actual creators and you’ll hear a different story. In June 2025, forums lit up after a viral screenshot showed a former OnlyFans creator venting about “clown show” content, platform drama, and fans burning out on recycled posts. People want freshness, respect, and a shot at going viral — not just a new home for the same old grind.

Bonnie Blue’s story is a case in point. After getting banned from OnlyFans (for pushing the envelope with taboo content and, let’s be real, a heavy dose of platform politics), she started over on Fansly — and didn’t even bother importing her old stuff. Seven pics, four vids, and a promise of “wilder, more real” collabs with college students and, yes, familiar faces. She went from zero to $100,000 in hours, and later told The Tab that her average monthly income jumped to €700,000 (that’s about $750k+ in U.S. money) — all with a leaner, more loyal fanbase (The Tab, 2025-06-23).

Bonzy, on the other hand, is where you’ll find up-and-comers looking to break in without fighting through the noise of old-school mega-creators. The lower fees mean even smaller accounts can pay their rent, and the AI tools are a lifesaver for anyone who doesn’t want to spend all day replying to DMs. Fans in the U.S. seem to love the “hidden” tip features (no more awkwardness — just drop a few bucks and bounce) and the fact that Bonzy feels a bit more underground. That said, some creators complain Bonzy’s moderation is looser, which can be a blessing or a curse depending on your brand.

Meanwhile, fans themselves are changing. According to TimeOut, New Yorkers alone dropped millions on subscriptions last year, but they’re getting picky: they want exclusive, authentic content, not just “another paywall” (TimeOut, 2025-06-23). TikTok and Discord are full of threads rating which platform “feels less scammy” or has “more real interaction.” Bonzy’s speed and Fansly’s curation are both big selling points — it’s just about what matters most to you.

And don’t sleep on the mental health angle. After the Skins star Megan Prescott went public about how “relentless” OnlyFans life can be, creators are seriously reevaluating where (and how) they share content. Platforms that offer better moderation, less drama, and more support are winning loyalty fast (LADbible, 2025-06-23).

🙋 Frequently Asked Questions

❓ Is Bonzy actually catching up to Fansly in 2025?

💬 Bonzy’s been making waves, especially with those fast payouts and lower platform fees. But Fansly still has the bigger, more loyal creator base and a more established fan community. If you’re new, Bonzy might feel less crowded, but for now, Fansly’s still king for big earners.

🛠️ Why are some creators leaving OnlyFans for these platforms?

💬 Honestly, a lot of folks got tired of the strict rules, payment headaches, or just wanted a fresh start (especially after drama like Bonnie Blue’s). Platforms like Fansly and Bonzy offer more freedom, better fan engagement, and sometimes better pay.

🧠 Can fans use both Fansly and Bonzy? Or do they have to pick one?

💬 You can totally use both! Most fans actually follow creators across multiple platforms, especially when exclusive content or deals drop. Just watch your wallet—those subscriptions add up fast in the U.S.!

🧩 Final Thoughts…

Here’s the real tea: the “Fansly vs Bonzy” debate isn’t about which platform has shinier features or even the fattest checks — it’s about what kind of creator (or fan) you wanna be. Fansly’s the safe bet for high-rollers and those who crave stability, killer moderation, and a polished community. Bonzy’s the scrappy upstart, giving underdogs and ambitious newbies a shot, with tech that actually saves you time (and maybe your sanity).

The smartest creators? They’re hedging their bets — testing both, cross-promoting, and letting fans decide. If you’re in it for the long haul, keep your eyes peeled: the landscape’s changing faster than ever, and what’s true today might not be tomorrow.

📚 Further Reading

Here are 3 recent articles that give more context to this topic — all selected from verified sources. Feel free to explore 👇

🔸 Amanda Bynes shares weight loss goal as she starts Ozempic after joining OnlyFans
🗞️ Source: Daily Mail – 📅 2025-06-23
🔗 Read Article

🔸 Skins star who now does OnlyFans reveals surprising reality about profession
🗞️ Source: LADbible – 📅 2025-06-23
🔗 Read Article

🔸 Here’s how much New Yorkers spent on OnlyFans last year (hint: it’s a lot)
🗞️ Source: TimeOut – 📅 2025-06-23
🔗 Read Article

😅 A Quick Shameless Plug (Hope You Don’t Mind)

If you’re creating on OnlyFans, Fansly, or similar platforms — don’t let your content go unnoticed.

🔥 Join Top10Fans — the global ranking hub built to spotlight creators like YOU.

✅ Ranked by region & category

✅ Trusted by fans in 100+ countries

🎁 Limited-Time Offer: Get 1 month of FREE homepage promotion when you join now!

📌 Disclaimer

This post blends publicly available information with a touch of AI assistance. It’s meant for sharing and discussion purposes only — not all details are officially verified. Please take it with a grain of salt and double-check when needed.